Center for Public Integrity

One of the main points of the creation of the Department of Homeland Security in 2004 was to centralize oversight over a wide array of agencies with responsibility for the safety and security of the United States and its territories. The 9/11 Commission made 41 specific recommendations to Congress, and one of those was “create a single, principal point of oversight and review for homeland security.” But that’s one that hasn’t been accomplished–DHS oversight by Congress is through 86 separate committees and subcommittees (see chart below, click on it for the full-sized image). The Center for Public Integrity and the Center for Investigative Reporting have joined forces to investigate the effectiveness of the Department of Homeland Security’s efforts since its creation, and will be publishing a series of reports over the next several months which should prove quite interesting.

As newspapers decline and die, it’s good to see other opportunities opening up to support investigative journalism. Along with wire services, which are beefing up their staffs and seeing growing profits as their content is syndicated to more and more places including websites and broadcast media, think tanks are also getting into the business. (There are also other nonprofits that support investigative journalism, such as the Center for Public Integrity.) The Goldwater Institute has hired investigative reporter Mark Flatten from the Tribune to investigate and report on cases of government corruption, abuse, and waste. Flatten is an award-winning reporter who has covered state government for nearly 20 years in Arizona, including covering the impeachment of former Gov. Evan Mecham, the AzScam corruption scandal, and the alternative fuels fiasco. Flatten is the only reporter who has ever been banned from the floor of the state legislature, which occurred at the order of former Arizona Speaker of the House Don Aldridge (R-Lake Havasu City) because of Flatten’s reporting on links between Aldridge and Max Dunlap, who was convicted for his part in the 1976 murder of Arizona Republic reporter Don Bolles. In 1976, Aldridge was a member of the Maricopa County Board of Supervisors, and he accompanied Dunlap to the law office of Neal Roberts on June 2, the day a bomb went off under Bolles’ car, allegedly about a runway paving problem at the Mohave County Airport (as reported in the Kingman Daily Miner, June 28, 1976). On June 3, Roberts and Dunlap met at Durant’s Restaurant to discuss raising $25,000 for the defense of Bolles’ killer, John Harvey Adamson, who was at the time facing a minor criminal charge and had not yet been caught for the murder. A May 10 NPR story describes the Goldwater Institute’s job ad for this position and raises concerns about political bias infecting any stories produced. While I think that’s a real concern, I think it’s often better to have stories come from an advertised bias rather than pretend objectivity. In any case, Flatten’s stories have gone after abuse regardless of party (Mecham was a Republican, the alternative fuels fiasco was caused by a Republican, and AzScam caught both Republicans and Democrats taking bribes). I look forward to seeing what he will investigate and write about in this new role. UPDATE (October 19, 2009): Flatten has published his first major investigative piece since being hired by the Goldwater Institute, and it’s an account of how a federal program designed to provide business opportunities to the disadvantaged is being used by political insiders for their own benefit, including County Supervisor Mary Rose Wilcox. Wilcox obtained the Chili’s Too franchise in Terminal 4 at Sky Harbor Airport as an Airport Concession Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (ACDBE), which requires that the owner participate in the day-to-day operation of the business, which she does not (though perhaps her co-owner does?). She also received a $450,000 loan from Host International which meant she didn’t have to bring any money to the table, a loan which violated city policy (the City of Phoenix owns and operates Sky Harbor). Flatten’s “High Fliers” report may be found here.

The Center for Public Integrity, an organization I support, has just published the results of an investigation into the roots of the recent economic crisis and the major players involved: The top subprime lenders whose loans are largely blamed for triggering the global economic meltdown were owned or backed by giant banks now collecting billions of dollars in bailout money — including several that have paid huge fines to settle predatory lending charges. The banks that funded the subprime industry were not victims of an unforeseen financial collapse, as they have sometimes portrayed themselves, but enablers that bankrolled the type of lending threatening the financial system. … According to the analysis: ...

The Center for Public Integrity has published a slew of new investigative reports: “Global Warming: Heated Denials” – reporting on climate change denialism pseudoscience from the Heartland Institute. “The Shadow Government” – 900 little-known federal advisory committees wielding influence over public policy. “Divine Intervention” – how the Bush Administration’s initiative to fight AIDS abroad is hampered by conservative ideology. “Broken Government” – an assessment of 128 executive branch failures since 2000. Check them out, and consider providing financial support for this organization, which is one of my top organizations to support. ...

The Center for Public Integrity has released details of a report from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention that has been blocked from publication for more than seven months. The report, titled Public Health Implications of Hazardous Substances in the Twenty-Six U.S. Great Lakes Areas of Concern, was supposed to be released in July 2007. The Center for Public Integrity has obtained the study, which warns that more than nine million people who live in the more than two dozen “areas of concern”—including such major metropolitan areas as Chicago, Cleveland, Detroit, and Milwaukee—may face elevated health risks from being exposed to dioxin, PCBs, pesticides, lead, mercury, or six other hazardous pollutants. ...

This should be considered old news, but the Center for Public Integrity has done an extensive analysis of statements made by the president, the vice president, and five other senior members of the Bush Administration between September 11, 2001 and September 2003 and identified 935 specific false statements made. These statements are now part of a searchable database, and they’ve put together a graph that shows how the frequency and number of false statements dramatically increased during the run up to the invasion of Iraq, and then declined as the truth became known in the course of the war: ...

The Center for Public Integrity has set up a “Media Tracker” based on FCC data by zip code which allows you to see how well-connected your zip code is. For each zip code, it will list the number of broadband providers and the number of owners of various media resources in your area (newspapers, radio and television stations. My zip code comes up as “well connected” with 18 broadband providers (a few more than the ones I identified in my survey of Phoenix-area broadband providers).

I received a mailing today from the “Protect 21 Coalition” asking me to contact my legislators to tell them to oppose Senate Bill 1276, which it describes as “alcohol deregulation.” The bill actually legalizes Internet-based sale of wine by Arizona wineries in the aftermath of the U.S. Supreme Court decision in Granholm v. Heald (which was combined with two other cases, including the Institute for Justice’s case from NY, Swedenburg v. Kelly), which held that state regulation of Internet-based wine sales must be the same for in-state and out-of-state wineries. A 1982 Arizona law permits only in-state wineries to ship wine to restaurants and retail stores, and so is unconstitutional under that decision. The Protect 21 website argues for a three-tier model of alcohol distribution (manufacturers, distributors, and retail sales) on the grounds that it is somehow better able to protect communities and prevent underage drinking. Actually, this model is an anti-competitive model held in place by regulations which benefit the middleman, whose role would otherwise disappear. Their main argument is that allowing wine sales over the Internet will lead to underage drinking, despite the fact that purchases require credit cards and deliveries require a signature and ID verification, same as a retail store purchase. (For more on this argument and discussion, see this Jacob Sullum post at Reason magazine’s blog.) And who would you guess is behind the Protect 21 Coalition? The two people who testified against Senate Bill 1276 on February 15 were Howard Romm, the president of Republic Beverage Company, and Marcus Osborn, the “Manager of Governmental and Public Affairs” of the Protect 21 Coalition. Actually, Osborn’s title is for his position at the Phoenix office of R&R Partners, a Las Vegas-based advertising and lobbying firm. Osborn is a busy lobbyist, who also testified on behalf of the “PACE Coalition” in favor of H.B. 2383, a bill for a “Program for All-inclusive Care for the Elderly” at taxpayer expense, on the same day. He’s also lobbied the Arizona legislature for Jack-in-the-Box restaurants and YUM brands. You can see Osborn’s lobbyist record with the state of Arizona here. The protect21.org domain was registered by R&R Partners, and the group’s mailing address listed on its website is a commercial postal mailbox at a branch of The UPS Store in downtown Phoenix. And who is a client of R&R Partners (though not listed on their website)? Republic Beverage Company, of course. If you’re in Arizona, contact your legislators and let them know that you’d rather not have your tax money spent to funnel money into the pockets of middlemen through archaic regulations, especially not to middlemen who hire lobbying firms to create fake grassroots efforts to promote their positions to the legislature. In 2004, expenditures by lobbyists had grown by 30% from 2003 to over $3 million, according to a study by the Center for Public Integrity.

Rep. John Boehner (R-OH) was named Speaker of the House to replace Tom DeLay. It’s already been pointed out that he lives in a D.C. apartment that belongs to a lobbyist. The Center for Public Integrity has looked further at his record, and found that he has taken dozens of trips on private jets owned by corporations that have legislative interests before Congresshas accepted scores of privately sponsored trips (often categorized as having fact-finding or educational purposes) to some of the world’s premier golf spots and foreign localeshas hosted many high-end fund-raisers to wine and dine potential donors and Republican colleagueshas donated millions of dollars to election campaigns of fellow Republicans.All legal, but the first two items are equivalent to receiving substantial gifts from special interests, and the second two are equivalent to passing some of them on and seeking more. The CPI’s website also has a Google Map of Boehner’s trips and expenses for 2005 which includes a Scottsdale, Arizona connection–he spent thousands of dollars at the Talking Stick Golf Club at 9998 E. Indian Bend Rd: DateAmount02/13/2004$3805.1302/13/2004$469.1302/13/2004$938.2603/07/2005$7488.67