Arizona

The chairman of the Arizona Democratic Party has admitted that the party gave $100,000 to the “Arizona Values Coalition” which funded the anti-Len Munsil website previously reported here. This comes after a denial by party spokesman Bart Graves on September 18. The site, which cost $1,250, has resulted in a payment of that amount to Munsil’s campaign from the Citizens Clean Elections Commission. Look, Democrats–use accurate information about Munsil to discredit him (of the sort that’s on the Len Munsil Facts website), and do so openly, rather than using deceptively-named groups like the “Arizona Conservative Trust.” If Munsil manages to come from far behind and win this election, the Democratic Party’s actions will be partly to blame. The Arizona Conservative Trust also paid for anti-Munsil pre-recorded telemarketing calls before the September 12 primaries.

Arizona Governor Janet Napolitano has a petition on her website to send to President Bush to ask him to ask Congress to take legislative action to mandate lower gasoline prices. This makes no sense. The best way to reduce dependence on gasoline and oil is for the prices to go up, not down. We’re taxing imports of Brazilian ethanol from sugar in order to promote corn-based products raised in the U.S., at the behest of companies like corporate welfare pig Archer Daniels Midland–how about stopping that? The Economist has frequently argued (most recently in its issue this month on climate change) that the U.S. should follow Europe’s lead by increasing taxes on gasoline as well as providing incentives to shift to alternative energy. Ellen Simon, a Democratic Party candidate from Sedona running against corrupt politician Rick Renzi in Arizona’s District 1, has “protecting the environment” on her list of issues, but she’s also pushing Napolitano’s “lower gas prices” petition. Why, Ellen? (BTW, thanks for the link to my Renzi/Hayworth post.) ...

University of Arizona professor Elif Shafak, who was tried in Turkey for “denigrating Turkish national identity” in her novel The Bastard of Istanbul, was acquitted. The EU has “welcomed” the verdict while expressing the opinion that Turkey should scrap these “insult” laws. I agree–and the EU member countries which have similar laws should do the same. Hat tip to stranger fruit.

A Len Munsil-critical website has appeared. It states that it is “paid for by the Arizona Conservative Trust” and has received funding from the Arizona Values Coalition. They’ve gone back to some of Munsil’s State Press editorials to find Munsil railing against student protests against apartheid in South Africa, calling it a “madness … afflicting college students around the nation." So far, they are missing Munsil’s position opposing the decriminalization of cohabitation and oral sex in Arizona. UPDATE: Munsil has complained about the “Arizona Conservative Trust” to the Clean Elections Commission, and his campaign is questioning who the donors are supporting it. An Arizona Republic article quotes Republican sleazebag and Munsil campaign consultant Nathan Sproul saying, “Who are the donors who are funding this thing? … They are engaging in a pretty offensive money-laundering operation." Sproul, former head of the Arizona Republican Party and the Arizona Christian Coalition, runs Sproul & Associates, which engaged in voter registration scams in multiple states prior to the 2004 election. Sproul set up groups that would represent themselves as nonpartisan “get out the vote” organizations in order to get Republicans registered to vote and discard or deter Democratic voter registrations. In addition to supporting Munsil, he also has worked on campaigns for U.S. Rep. Trent Franks, a former Arizona legislator who was a single-issue (anti-abortion) candidate. Sproul has received significant funding from the Republican National Committee to engage in dirty tricks. I agree with the Munsil campaign’s statement that the name “Arizona Conservative Trust” is misleading and deceptive, especially if (as seems likely) there are Democratic Party members behind the effort. I also condemn the prerecord telemarketing pseudo-surveys that have been done (“push polls”) regarding Munsil–it’s a sleazy tactic.

Ed Brayton rightly criticizes the Arizona Civil Liberties Union’s lawsuit to try to prevent Arizona from giving corporate tax credits for donations to organizations that provide private school tuition for students from low-income families. The AzCLU has previously failed in two lawsuits to eliminate the state income tax credit for individual donations to private school tuition organizations. There is no reason to believe this third lawsuit will be anything but a waste of money. As Ed points out, this is not a violation of the establishment clause of the Constitution (or the Arizona Constitution’s prohibition on state funds being used to promote religion) because no state funds are going directly to any religious organization. I support the Institute for Justice on this issue, and this is a reason I’ve never given funds to the AzCLU (though I support the ACLU Foundation). I am a beneficiary of the individual state tax credit–I annually make the maximum qualifying contribution to the Arizona School Choice Trust, which is the single most efficient charity I donate to (100% of donations are distributed as tuition payments for students from low-income families; salaries for employees and administrative overhead are paid by another private organization). UPDATE (June 7, 2007): Judge Janet Barton granted the Institute for Justice’s motion to dismiss this case, back in March. UPDATE (March 12, 2009): The Institute for Justice won this case again today in the Arizona Court of Appeals.

Former Arizona State University student president Yaser Alamoodi, still a student at ASU, was arrested at 6 a.m. on September 6 by Immigration and Customs Enforcement officers. They took him to Eloy (about halfway between Phoenix and Tucson), where he sits in a detention center. The 29-year-old Tempe resident came to the U.S. from Saudi Arabia in 1996 under a student visa. He describes himself as “extremely secular. I was the president of my university. I have a commitment to everything America stands for, women’s rights to civil rights.” But because he married a U.S. citizen and they agreed to divorce in August, the divorce process invalidated his pending green card application. And because his passport and citizenship are from Yemen, the country where his father was born but which he’s never been in, that’s where he will be deported to. His attorney says he can stay in detention in Eloy and fight the deportation for six months to “years,” he can allow himself to be deported to Yemen and try to get a student visa to return to finish his degree, or if his wife stops the divorce process he would be allowed to stay.

John McCain continues his pandering to the religious right by endorsing Republican candidate for Governor of Arizona, Len Munsil. Munsil, who attended Arizona State University at the same time I did, was editor of the ASU newspaper, the State Press. Now he runs an extremist religious right policy organization, the Center for Arizona Policy, which opposed the removal of Arizona’s laws banning cohabitation and oral sex. (They were removed anyway, by a moderate female Republican Governor, Jane Dee Hull.) Munsil drafted Arizona’s law on marriage (which defines marriage to preclude gay marriage) and is behind Proposition 107, the Protect Marriage Arizona Amendment, which amends the Arizona Constitution to prohibit the creation of civil unions or the granting of any legal status for unmarried persons that is similar to marriage. I’ve previously written about Munsil here, where I describe how he refused to print a letter to the editor I wrote criticizing factual errors in an editorial he wrote in the State Press. You can find out more about Munsil and his supporters and detractors at this Arizona Republic blog entry, “Munsil: I’m a Reagan, Kyl-style Republican." I’ve left a number of comments there. ...

Rep. Jim Kolbe (R, AZ District 8) is not running for re-election, so there are five Republicans seeking the nomination. Republican National Committee Chairman Ken Mehlman, in a meeting with four of those five and a representative of the fifth in Tucson on March 30, told them that the RNC would not intervene in the primaries, but rather would devote its funds to assisting the campaigns of whoever the local Republicans of District 8 selected to represent them. The RNC changed its mind, however, and spent $122,000 on advertising for candidate Steve Huffman, its preferred candidate. Randy Graf, who is the current front-runner for the nomination, issued a joint press release with the other Republican candidates (minus Huffman) condemning Mehlman and the RNC for their dishonesty and broken promise. Huffman has criticized Graf for being slow to fire a campaign manager who had a conviction for “corrupting young girls” but has in turn been embarrassed by allegations that his own campaign treasurer, Bill Arnold, took photos through the windows of the home of Huffman’s ex-wife, state senator Toni Hellon. The photos were used to create a website apparently designed to discredit her if Huffman were to have run against her for her state legislative position. Hellon has sued Arnold for invasion of privacy, but apparently supports her ex-husband’s nomination. Graf is also a member of the Minuteman Project. District 8 is fairly evenly divided between Republicans and Democrats, with the former having about a 5% advantage. Looks like it will be a dirty race.

Phoenix made the list of Forbes magazine’s “drunkest cities” in America, coming in at #22. 35 cities for which the appropriate data were available were ranked on levels of alcoholism (actually, based on number of Alcoholics Anonymous meetings in the city), number of binge drinkers (from CDC survey data), per-capita drinkers (from CDC survey data), per-capita heavy drinkers (from CDC survey data), and state laws about alcohol (with least restrictive laws counting towards “drunkest”–it would be interesting to see if there is any correlation between this measure and the others). The specific ranking measurements are described here. The full list: 1. Milwaukee 2. Minneapolis-St. Paul 3. Columbus 4. Boston 5. Austin 6. Chicago 7. Cleveland 8. Pittsburgh 9. Philadelphia (tie) 9. Providence (tie) 11. St. Louis 12. San Antonio (tie) 12. Seattle (tie) 14. Las Vegas 15. Denver/Boulder 16. Kansas City (tie) 16. Cincinnati (tie) 18. Houston 19. Portland 20. San Francisco-Oakland (tie) 20. Washington-Baltimore (tie) 22. Phoenix 23. Los Angeles 24. New Orleans (tie) 24. Tampa (tie) 26. Norfolk 27. Dallas-Fort Worth 28. Atlanta (tie) 28. Detroit (tie) 30. Indianapolis 31. Orlando 32. New York 33. Miami 34. Charlotte 35. Nashville

In the Arizona Republic: “As GOP stalwarts try to distance themselves from former House Majority Leader Tom DeLay, Arizona’s Rep. Trent Franks has remained by his side. “The embattled DeLay spoke at a Franks fund-raiser on Capitol Hill in December. Franks gave $4,200 to DeLay’s re-election committee in March, nearly six months after the then-Texas congressman was indicted by a grand jury on money-laundering and conspiracy charges. . . . ...